Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), formerly NASD, recently fined Morgan Stanley & Co. Incorporated US$1.5m and ordered the firm to pay more than US$4.6m in restitution for rule violations relating to the sale of corporate bonds to retail customers at excessive prices. The firm was cited for charging excessive mark-ups in more than 2,800 transactions and for having an inadequate supervisory system for monitoring the pricing of corporate fixed income securities sold to customers.
The firm's corporate bond trader, who was responsible for setting the excessive prices, Kenneth S. Carberry III, was fined US$40,000 jointly and severally with the firm and suspended in all capacities for 15 business days.
FINRA found that during a five-month period in 2001, Morgan Stanley charged markups ranging from 5.88% to 17.86% on 2,807 sale transactions of Kemper Lumbermans Mutual Casualty Surplus Notes in the 9.15% and 8.30% series, with a face value totaling over US$59 million.
In pricing the securities, the firm's corporate fixed income securities trader, Carberry, established the offering price, to which a sales commission was added. However, the firm's procedures failed to provide for a review of the mark-ups charged using the prevailing market price at the time, which in this case was best evidenced by the firm's cost for acquiring the bonds that it later sold to customers. The pricing method used by Carberry and the firm resulted in excessive prices paid by its customers. These transactions were conducted out of the firm's main office in New York City.
In addition, FINRA found that the firm failed to have a supervisory system in place that would have allowed the firm to detect the excessive mark-ups, and failed to properly register the individual responsible for review of the trading activities.
No comments:
Post a Comment